On June 19, 2024, and July 8, 2025, Toledo Police faced two separate armed-suspect incidents that rapidly escalated into officer-involved shootings. This bodycam case study examines the Joshua Garner and Aaron Soll encounters, including 911 calls, police bodycam footage, tactical decisions, and the eventual court outcomes. In the first incident, Toledo Police responded to reports of an armed man threatening people in a residential neighborhood. The suspect, Joshua Garner, fled from the responding officer while armed with a handgun. During the pursuit, the encounter escalated into an exchange of gunfire between Garner and the officer. Remarkably, neither Garner nor the officer was struck. Garner was taken into custody and faced multiple charges, including felonious assault, domestic violence, improperly discharging a firearm, and tampering with evidence. In January 2025, Garner was found not guilty by reason of insanity on charges stemming from the incident. In the second incident, Toledo Police responded to a domestic violence call involving Aaron Soll. Officers met with the victim and observed noticeable injuries to her face before approaching the apartment where Soll had gone. Soll eventually emerged from the apartment armed with a firearm and failed to comply with officers’ commands. An officer fired, striking Soll in the hand. Soll retreated into the apartment before later surrendering and being taken into custody. This case study examines the incident using publicly released police bodycam footage, dashcam video, surveillance footage, cellphone video, 911 calls, dispatch audio, witness recordings, and investigative findings, when available. Analysis and commentary are provided from the perspective of a former federal agent, former law enforcement officer, and digital forensics examiner. Whether you are an aspiring law enforcement officer, a current officer, criminal justice student, attorney, first responder, or simply interested in public safety, these case studies are designed to highlight tactical decision making, officer safety principles, legal considerations, and practical lessons that can be applied to real-world law enforcement encounters. ⚠️ VIEWER DISCRETION ADVISED ⚠️ This video contains real police bodycam footage from a critical incident that some viewers may find disturbing. This content is presented for educational, training, legal analysis, news reporting, and public awareness purposes only. All individuals featured are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This content is not intended to shame, harass, or encourage harassment of any individual. Viewers are encouraged to approach these incidents thoughtfully, especially when mental health challenges, emotional distress, substance impairment, or other factors may contribute to rapidly evolving encounters. FAIR USE NOTICE This content is used under Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976 for purposes including criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, research, and educational analysis. Texas Safety Watch uses publicly released materials to provide tactical breakdowns, legal context, officer safety discussion, and public awareness regarding real-world law enforcement incidents. RECOMMENDED PROFESSIONAL RESOURCES Texas Safety Watch encourages viewers to learn from multiple professional perspectives. For additional tactical, legal, and officer safety education, we recommend the following YouTube channels: • Sgt. Curtis (@SergeantCurtis) – My personal favorite for police tactics, use-of-force decision-making, and real-world law enforcement training. He is an excellent instructor who explains complex situations in a clear and practical way. Highly recommended for new recruits, aspiring law enforcement officers, and anyone interested in a career in law enforcement. • @TheSergeantSteve – A great mix of humor and education. Sgt. Steve has a unique ability to make complex incidents easy to understand while keeping viewers engaged and reinforcing important lessons. • Midwest Safety (@MidwestSafety) – Professional analysis of unique law enforcement incidents, officer survival, and concise, well-produced case summaries. • Law Talk With Mike (@LawTalkWithMike) – Attorney providing legal analysis, courtroom commentary, constitutional law discussions, and criminal justice topics. • The Civil Rights Lawyer (@TheCivilRightsLawyer) – Constitutional law, civil rights litigation, police accountability, and legal analysis of real-world law enforcement encounters from a civil rights attorney. Each provides valuable insight into officer safety, tactical decision making, use of force, leadership, and real-world law enforcement training. If you value professional tactical and legal analysis of real-world police incidents, consider subscribing to Texas Safety Watch. #TexasSafetyWatch #PoliceBodycam #PoliceTraining #OfficerSafety #LawEnforcement #OfficerInvolvedShooting

Texas Safety Watch police bodycam Toledo Police bodycam police bodycam footage officer involved shooting police shooting bodycam armed suspect bodycam Joshua Garner Toledo Aaron Soll Toledo Toledo Police shooting police training law enforcement training officer safety Sgt Curtis Midwest Safety