On September 26, 2024, 34-year-old mother of three Brianne Otley was shot inside her home in Greenville, Ohio. Her ex-boyfriend, Zachery Gilbert, was arrested just blocks away. Gilbert told investigators he had been drinking, was angry and jealous, and had his finger on the trigger when Brianne was shot. He claims it was just a tragic accident. But investigators would later uncover a chilling piece of evidence inside Brianne’s bedroom: a pillow with a bullet hole through it.