no no [Music] pleas please please look at this though this guy's searching me dude he's got me in handcuffs you're sitting there rolling up like you got your light on and you're on my property he's still scared he's scared am I right or am I wrong you scared right is that how we do it on the East side right you want these hands you can have them I won't even arrest you son you scared in today's world where every interaction can be instantly recorded body cam footage not only captures raw moments of human conflict but also provides a crucial window into how state laws are applied in real time the cases below span a spectrum of scenarios showing the challenges officers face while in the field and prompts us to ask how do the letter and spirit of the law hold up when human nature gets in the way yeah there's one line tell them to stop okay down there all right I'm putting this vehicle out of the way on the shoulder God damn it open I can't get out of this vehicle come here uh they want to talk to you who uh the man yeah you all right I'm pissed my pants are ripped I have scrap on my knee and my wrist this officer got dragged to the ground while in a dispute with golf champion Scotty sheffler the officer was trying to stop sheffer's car from driving toward an accident site that had occurred earlier in the day apparently the interaction did not go well leading to sheffer's arrest what we have to do okay we're getting you checked out alls ride or do you want no I'm not that bad just my knee no we're taking you to get looked at not go get looked at once you my pants are ripped did you get the name of the player yet I don't have his information yet I was just trying to get his um vehicle out of the way so he can move everything she coming down here I'm going to stick him with you all right he's going to make sure to do like the injured employee and all the other different stuff whether they PJ or not you control your scene they can fit on the top right it's like he went around everybody else we already had a line of them trying to come in and he decided he's going you recording no it wasn't at the time was wasn't expecting to be run over yeah you're not under Kentucky law offenses like assault and battery are defined by specific elements such as intent and demonstrable harm in this case the body cam footage revealed that the physical contact was a byproduct of miscommunication rather than a premeditated attack the dismissal of charges underscores how kuy's statutory framework requires clear evidence of Criminal Intent a threshold that wasn't met in this turbulent encounter everything was distressed at this I'm sure the cars I mean it's just warm I'm not worried about it it's just like he goes he goes I'm going to go my hands on and like I like no you're not he I'm going to go he floors it yeah what you got do yeah it's unfortunate but that's what it is St told me he's he's going to go couldn't find his I'm going try to see if I can get us information can you find out where he put his wallet at hey Scotty hey man where in your car is your wallet just so we can get all your stuff together my the side of your gym bag I got for you too what I got all of hiso okay I mean I was looking at the gym bag I didn't see in where in the gym bag there's a mesh pocket inside are you are you the one that I I mean you hurt my wrist my ankle knee and my ripped my pants wait I'm directing traffic it says police on me employ so the guy Vis like where you're at we some car trying to pull in and I go St hold up I'm trying to turn [Music] sir I'm right here on the south entrance uh where everybody's turning in at gate one he's getting checked out okay this [Music] hurts oh here it is for radio the corner van is on his way now oh [Applause] traic 200 R I'm okay that we the this initial case sets the tone by demonstrating that even well-intentioned law enforcement actions can devolve into chaos it raises a critical question when every second counts are our legal standards flexible enough to account for the unpredictability of human interactions hey you okay yeah my wrist hurts my knee hurts ran me over yeah some of the guys the W million like got Dr my b all right so what you got want or not can't remember it's torn up but I don't feel anything right now until I dress I don't know what the a way to have another fatal let the God damn it I know mine did turn on like three times in a row I need pictures of you is that the vehicle yep guys watch back while moving up there we're going have put back Lan right now man to you got a lot of play right now as we start getting people uh to their traffic points coming through gate one just sending this way we'll be out here to make sure they get where they need to go so you have my wrist they are all right my knee I know of uh kill the light there again and then they RI my pants all four charges against sheffler were dismissed as it was all the result of a misunderstanding you know what I'm not answering any questions this is my bike Michael Willie chill out I'm chilling out you ran up on me it's my bike dude I have did you take a bike from here earlier that's a stolen bike right there dude the wrong one huh that's my bike that's not my bike I didn't take a bike from here that's my bike chill out chill out we just took a report no just give second take aort give me a second you have any weapons on you man no you know that too what you why you search me you have a knife right here buddy that's a pen this is a knife that's not a okay I'm just going to put you in cops right now till I get things figured out chill out this is a few street though isn't it I'm just trying to figure out which one just put your hands behind your back I'm not okay come over here come over here 133 I have Robert Willie in detained right now you do what okay do you have any other weapons on you got another knife listen hey do you have any other receips for that hey chill out there is no weapons on me you're making it a weapon you're making it a weapon now and that's my Pap we got got you back up dude not bad let me put him in front of me I'm sorry officer but you got the wrong guy you there's another officer on the way you don't got to report on me I'm telling you right now this man was arrested for threatening people a witness said a man on a bike yelled at him making it seem like he had a weapon officers quickly responded to the call and caught him Texas law as outlined in the Texas Penal Code treats offenses such as theft and assault with particular attention to the use of force and the context in which property disputes occur for instance aggravated assault and theft require clear evidence of intent and harm sorry about that am I in trouble for that it drove itself very much can I drve this one what's up don't do that you're rolling me aren't you all right I apologize what do you got me on this time drunken disorderly are you drunk maybe dude I don't know hey you're booking me aren't you you're detaining me still and you're doing all this you're underr prove what cuz you had a couple knives on you you're a felon no I'm not what do you mean you're not it's got Walker's act they're not weapons man they weren't concealed home field hey there officer sorry about running at your car I apologize obviously this is going to make up for it right a night in jail or never getting released this time good luck I know and for him for the bike then no I that's my he the suspect on the bike that huh you guys said that in police dude when I was last rested last time I have the receipt hey chill out that's what we were going to ask you I have the receipt then calm down goodness gracious I'm not just going to said you're look at this though this guy's searching me dude he's got me in handcuffs you're sitting there rolling up like you got your lights on and you're on my property that is all right we're going to go over here over okay fine over here over here yes in the front seat come on definitely not in the front seat thank you I got it I got it I got it I got it no you go talk to him that you guys will run the numbers you'll see it was in fle pound less than a week ago my friend is it Monday today October 14th yes it is thank [Applause] you I'll call the ladies in this incident the suspect's prior felony status and the rapid escalation put officers in a position where they had to balance assertive intervention with the risk of overreach the unfolding events illustrate the delicate application of Texas statutes when ambiguity RS on the streets he was arrested on two counts of theft and resisting arrest no no please no go please please please please please come out here ma'am come out here all right you want to tell me what happened sure he he locked a door uh with two babies inside and get the out like this and hurt me how did he get you out tell me how he got you out like this he grabbed that and then how did you hurt your elbow because I I tried to go in I'm right here right you tried to go in what happened he lock the door okay explain to me how he hurt your elbow he lock a door with two babies inside right I can't go in okay I haven't got shoes I haven't got nothing how did he hurt your elbow how did it hurt what did he do that you hurt your elbow he put me and the like take me like my is no good it's okay it's okay but he he grabbed me and take all the F okay meet a Florida man caught in a domestic Showdown featuring himself his breakfast burrito and his intoxicated Russian wife when deputies arrived tensions boiled over as the wife accused him of abuse sparking a heated exchange all caught on body cam I don't know if she's drinking now look at her tea she stained with wine you know I'm sitting out here with my neighbor doing the same I'm sitting here at home right now cuz I'm afraid for my kid I'm trying to help her I I I I'm trying to come back in my country because I'm I'm I'm scared here okay I understand but what happened that you that you guys got into this argument are there any guns or anything in the house no don't understand is there guns pow pow the incident is is framed by Florida statute which addressed domestic violence and Battery respectively these laws are designed to protect individuals from abuse while ensuring that proper legal procedures like the reading of Miranda rights are followed even in the midst of chaos you guys knowwhere to go I understand that I'm just you know I I I regardless of how horrible it is uh I know that she has nothing right so catch up in my head like dude I got sh yeah I see red right there my door off you have any other you have any injuries on you no me it's not injuries it's not anything like that we' done been through this twice so before she would R for the same thing she has a battery charg on you yes that two weeks ago man the footage not only documents the physical altercation but also highlights the constitutional rights afforded to all parties reinforcing the complex balance between personal grievances and legal accountability in domestic settings I'm eating breakfast and get slammed and beating I don't swing on people I don't do nothing I don't have a record listen there's no reason to get upset I'm upset I'm just stressing my opinion it's I apologize all right I'm here listening to you I this I don't know what to do I I'm going through a citizenship deal uh she's got a little bit of I don't know is DCF comes over they put a safety plan in play I try to take it off of it I go to the district attorney I try to drop the battery charge she's still going on she's got a no drinking claws whatever it is it's still on her deal it's still it's still pending I'm trying to do whatever it is for our family to live whatever it is but I I can't deal with it he dangered I'm already to call a Russian Embassy because he dangered and why don't you leave because I hav with nothing when you say he's dangerous has he hit you before yes how I don't want to show you okay you have to you have to give me something okay he take me like this and put out the house and block block the house that was today yes what about other times other time right okay as you run this right here on your neck uh real quick let me see your head keep right here camera real quick have you uh ever looked in a restrain order anybody man this is what I know what you're trying to do so hard this is went so hard I I I'm in I'm in a I'm in a citizen B citizenship bath he put me down and lock at like a house with two babies inside what made him do that what made him maybe because I'm around him he hate me he hates you he hate me oh you okay did did did did he ever hit you or no yes he is where did he hit you you wait do you have something under that or no you have clothes under that yes where right here and you're right on your elbow huh where else I can show you more photo from my phone okay well I'm talking about right now not before right now he he El he he pick up me like this and get out of a house so he grabb you by your neck can I see can I see can you turn around sure sure but he grabbed me over CLA this and take out of the house and look and and Lo and lock a house that I can't go inside Maria have you been drinking today I I I drink one beer so Maria how did the did did uh Brenan there get food all over his head and how does he have a bunch of red marks around his shoulders neck and the back of his head can you show me because I'm not doing it I'm I'm telling you that's what I saw maybe a kid's doing it you know what this is Miranda warnings you know what that is I'm going to ask you some self-incriminating questions that I don't want you to feel you have answer without a lawyer you understand that we have a better understanding of what's going on here right you understand what do you not understand I I'm not understand what what this mean okay do you speak English I'm I'm 5050 how about this I'm going to read this to you and if you understand it you say yes and if you don't you say no please repeat okay so before we ask you any questions you must understand your rights you understand that okay you know what rights are rights US citizen rights okay you the right to remain silent you understand that you the right to to be quiet okay do you understand each of these rights I've explained do you understand everything I said a little bit yes this law comes from the Miranda versus Arizona 1966 ruling by the US Supreme Court it is part of the Miranda warnings which law enforcement must give to individuals in custody before interrogation to protect their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination have you been arrested before for domestic battery yes against brandan yes he against me what happened uh he said that I'm danger for him when did that happen 15 of December this past December mhm okay and but what happened did you hit him he hit you or what no nothing just it just fight just fight okay according to theill illo law Maria had already been charged with battery on 15th of December where she had previously assaulted her husband in the past too when you destroyed the inside of the house yesterday you show me pictures because you were drunk okay and then last night you got into an argument about it which carried on to this morning and this morning and last night he cleaned everything up which is how the house is now you guys were arguing did he bring McDonald's for breakfast for you guys no well there for yourself maybe for your okay and then you guys were arguing you picked up the the burrito he was eating and you hit him in the head because even when I was there talking to him he still had egg pieces in his head okay there's no way your little girl was able to go and laun eggs or burritos on top of his head all right and then he started saying you started you went you went outside he closed the door on you you busted the door hold on stop there's a bunch of handprints claw Mark we'll call we'll call it hand drags on on the window from you trying to get in and once he let you in you started beating him he has big he has he has fist imprints right here right here right here on the back of his neck and there how'd that get how'd that happen can can I can I get my phone and show you what how did that I'm talking about today how did that happen did you hit him I I I I I pushed him you didn't punch him no I'm not so how how how did he get all red right here in the back how that happened ask him I'm asking you cuz he told I did he told me it was you look at myself look at myself right now I know I see can can can I can I do it probably yes especially if you've done it before this guy put me out all house lock a house and say that I can't be around my keys so that gives you right to go and start hitting them and throw burritos this case injects a dose of dark humor into our examination reminding us that even the most surreal moments like a breakfast burrito becoming evidence are subject to strict legal scrutiny it underscores the question in a world where personal disputes can go viral how can our legal systems ensure fairness and and Clarity I guarantee if I grab your fist and I go like this and I put it against his skin with the redness that's there it's going to be pretty much very close in size and it it's very consistent to what he said you punched him in the arm punched him in the chest and in the back of the head where he has a big fist imprint right here and another one right there all right so what do you have to say about that so you telling him he you that you went and you sprinkled the burrito on his head and you pushed him and that was it I put a burrito on his head he pick up me on the bat go out like like this was that after you hit him no when was that okay well turn around put your hands behind your back you're going to Y tonight for domestic battery so give me your hand thank you you little cozy cozy you understand why right you're the primary aggressor you guys are married you have kids in common all right I'm calling the government stop I'm calling the government now if you start pulling away you're going to get another charge no no no no let's go seat you mind pleas please please deputies arrested Maria Howard under Florida statutes for domestic violence and Battery despite her claims physical evidence and her husband's account identified her as the primary aggressor how we doing bud better huh what's going on man what's going on man well my daughter she just like flipped out a while ago I B A money deal tells me I ow I owe her like 40 bucks which ain't hers so she started flipping out yeah she done turned over a couple totes then broke my glass table that was on my front porch okay so yeah she's having a trip over right now she already got domestic she she she's been in trouble with police in the past they said that sh on juvenile for that they get that's domestic the other two officers that responded like less than a week ago about the same type of thefuck didn't do and it's been an ongoing damn thing and she's one point away from juvenile but they won't take her yeah well that has nothing to do with us as far as them taking her or not you know what I mean but what uh where where she at man [ __ ] you make a big ass circle around here she ain't she could G she busted a glass table which table's no good but she still had no business breaking my glass table absolutely she took off yeah do you know which way she went no I didn't see I was went that way stuff she went she went that way Jers and a sweatshirt you want to see if you can find her I mean we got at least criminal damage that's criminal damage that's domestic come on she at least getting two charges and if y' don't give her both charges I want both y badge numers the final case brings us to Springfield where a body cam captures a highly charged altercation between a seasoned officer and a defiant teenager raw language aggressive gestures and a palpable breakdown in protocol paint a picture of an encounter spiraling out of control well you know what no offense but if you're going to hear okay keep walking then keep walking then yeah he always says that badge number and all this yeah F first of all you're not a police officer right did you go to law school did you go to police officer school you have a badge did you go through the academy so do you know the charges or no so you went to court once or twice so all of a sudden now you know the law I so you went to court once or twice so all of a sudden now you know the law first of all don't tell me how to do my job I'm I just got here I just got here you don't even know me if you want to do something do something then son Bas little kid he just basically say I just got here trying to threaten me son you call me over here and then you trying to threaten me son godamn call you I to slap you on some Silvers and take you down the county godamn that's what I got to do cuz what you going to do false arrest you you didn't just point that stick at me you didn't just point that stick at me your camera is your camera on you see that red dot it's on it's on it's on with your scary ass sure watch what you say you watch what you say you watch what you say kid I don't know who you think you talking to but first of all you don't talk to me like that you understand that I'm here to help you I'm here to help you and all of a sudden before I even got here you like y'all ain't going to do I just got here you with your scary I'm right here I'm right here you a rookie shut up that's police brutality is it yeah [ __ ] is it cuz you went to court once or twice you mean I know my laws ma'am if we find her she's going to be arrested for criminal damage did she hit you today [ __ ] shut the up did she hit you today I'm not a you watch your MTH on the she did hit you today she did I know where the we at America really America you don't see this brait right here what have you done for America what you done for this America clean up the glass you ain't done shut up shut up scared I'm right here man you scared you scared scared as soon as I put my hands on your I know how it's going to go I I'm not even going to take you to jail I'll give you the freedom of that man you a goddamn love you want to put one or two [ __ ] really see I'm not stupid you ain't about to mace me I won't even I'm turning down my radio so I can hear the [ __ ] coming out of your mouth really I call you out here for my purpose and you and my son are come on now really well first of all your son's got mouth on him and now I can see why your daughter's acting all out of control so first of all discipline needs to be an issue all right shut the up shut discipline needs to be an issue man obviously there's a ju obviously there's disciplinary issue right here put me in no damn okay okay you want to throw some hands man we can throw some hands and I won't even arrest you man I'll let you go right in there oh like I've never heard that before like I've never heard that before like I've never heard that before back to so I ain't from Mexico you stupid Mexico I ain't from Mexico [ __ ] you mean so anyways that's what we're looking at right here so if my partner can find her that's what we're going to go with okay hopefully she'll make enough points and then we can take her to to ysb can I have your badge number I want your badge the juvenile detention center I have that I need that I need that badge sir so however if she come if she comes back here you need before we find her you need to give us a call so we can come back and address the issue of all this earlier you understand what I'm saying so just cuz we don't find her now doesn't mean she's going to get skap she's going to escape free you know what I mean Hest understand but where she go though I don't have no clue I don't know who she know or who she don't know I don't know okay I don't know none of my kids friends or nothing that's fine that's fine so she's mad about 40 bucks well 40 bucks is legally mine and she says I owe it to her she's a juvenile she ain't got no money entitled to her period I don't owe kids anything no you don't mom does not owe kid nothing no no absolutely thank you thank no mom does not owe kid nothing no so you should be good to go and besides the fact whether that that table was good or not it still doesn't give her the right to do all this no it wasn't right for right it it was much less put her hands on you either so has she done that before yeah in the past she has about how many times oh God that many about that many yeah okay but my question is if she if she found if y'all find her she go to jail she goes to court tomorrow she's a judge whatever whatever whatever unfortunately what the judge does after that is beyond me he's above me all day the next day the Jud whatever yeah that's the gra Park Illinois Law as codified in the Illinois compiled statutes governs offenses ranging from assault and battery to criminal damage the heated interaction in this case Complicated by the involvement of a minor highlights the stringent legal standards that dictate both officer conduct and the treatment of juvenile offenders this confrontation forces a closer look at how these statutes are enforced in real time especially when emotions run High and the line between discipline and excessive force becomes BL can I have your can I have your badge I mean you just pushed me I mean I once that number I pushed you yeah you pushed the on me dude oh really I once that number so you scared now no i a i your number though can't touch you I can touch your number yeah me I told you you could number I told you you could you give me told you you told I told you if you I told you if you want to throw hands no I'm not going to touch you you [ __ ] cuz you scared cuz you scared dude scared dude why don't you want to give me scared dude what's your last name man what is it I'm sorry yeah you scared dude you can keep running your mouth but you still ain't going to do nothing I'm standing right here you still ain't going to do nothing you still got your fagg cuz you scared would y'all come get your brother please would y'all come get your brother please you can't control them no you can't control them that's yeah I can tell I can tell I can put some hands on oh okay push you again right and then and then I do it and you still ain't going to do nothing and you still ain't all day you still ain't going to do nothing still ain't going to do I'm right here man I'm right here damn is that all y'all do on the east side is that all you do on these side is run your goddamn mouth you all think we're just a bunch of you think I supposed to show up and have you run mouth come on then come on then I'm right here push you again I pushed you once and you scared that's why you didn't do nothing you scared my camera is on it's my camera's been on my camera's been on you scared come you little CL scared camera right next to you you scared right better keep that camera you scared you want me to leave it in my car is that what you want that camera you want me to leave it in my car you keep you better keep that whole damn what do you want me to do for you to put some hands on me just come back over you want me to put my pistol away you want me to pull my badge away come back over without your uniform okay I'll be back tonight then yeah come back tonight okay come back tonight but in the meantime I'm right here no I'm not going to touch you why you got of course not you're not you scared son you run your mouth but you scared I just ain't going to get in that charge you run your M he scared I just told him I wasn't going to arrest him I told I'm not even going to tase you I'm not even going to Ma you I'm going to give you these hands and you still going to run your mind you still scared he scared am I right or am I wrong you scared right is that how we do it on the East side right you want these hands you can have them I won't even arrest you son you scared you that's what you is you a that's why everybody around here going Punk your cuz you ain't nothing but a what's your last name man' dude I'm done with you dude if you ain't going to throw hands and shut if youin if you ain't gonna throw hands do something yeah did I not just touch you huh did I not just touch you okay got one here one here one here police fighting police fighting he's good he's good he's good don't do it don't do it R start first that's bad you all right put your hands behind your back put your hands behind your back he's good don't do it don't do it what the all right hold on what don't arrest him don't arrest him see I thought it was going to be a one one what type was that my partner didn't [ __ ] do nothing you man what's up you scared what's up I'm scared I'm scared H scar we're done we're done we ain't done we're done done is not done on this he's running in mouth so cameras right on the floor that's right yeah like I told you dud You Ain't About That Life kid I told you I told you you ain't about that life going inside like I told you man don't do that I'm telling you don't do again don't talk to me like that don't talk to me like that man I'm not involved with that done man you done what's your first name I'm sorry man I'm [Applause] sorry 49 you guys good oh I'm [Music] good know that that wasn't fair man why didn't you let me slam that I didn't touched you man man but you came up behind me with that tast don't don't don't talk don't talk to me like that man man why don't you let me SL not invol why you let me talk put my hands be my word youry r I'm sorry but I'm true to my word I was going to knock your ass to youry I told put your hands behind your back now you when you on your back over there on the corner as soon as I heard get on dude I felt bad for you that's why I sto hitting you yeah shut up you mean you can never take me oneone I just did no you did you really I just did you really did I just did you really did I just did you know the funny part is nobody came to help you like funniest nobody came to help you terminated by the city on May 9th Samuel Rosario faces charges of official misconduct and battery in connection with the beating of Robert Humes and is put on probationary leave [Music]