When presented with phone records, the gun she had purchased, and details of her affair, she admitted that she and Queller had been plotting the murder of Tyrone for months. They wanted to get a $400,000 life insurance payout and proceed with their affair. Kima would stage the murder to look like a random act by staying inside and dialing 911. When Tyrone was murdered, she made the 911 call, acting sad and surprised. But secretly, she knew what had occurred. Kemier was arrested on January 12th, 2019, the day of Tyrone's funeral, adding a layer of betrayal as she had been helping plan the service while concealing her role in his death. He even stood over Tyrone's body and fired one last shot into him to make sure his victim was dead. Kemier and Quua were both charged with murder.