4. Ma'am, >> why did I pay for mom? Mom, no. Hannah, I'm let go. >> What is going to happen? >> Is this the underwear you gave me, Mom? >> For how long, >> ma'am? Is it Ask her if it's a pink pair under Ask her if it's a pink pair of underwear. ASK HER. I'M WEARING THEM. OH MY GOSH. ASK HER IF it's a pink pair underwear. I'll take them off. >> October 16th, 2023, Rocky River area, Ohio. A woman's delivery package, 15 items, $400, was taken from a neighboring porch and documented by delivery confirmation photographs. >> Here. >> Hello. >> So, this is this is And I wouldn't care, but it's like $400 worth of stuff. It won't show up, but So, that's their front porch. There's the package. Okay. >> With that little black thing right there. >> Yeah. And so, um, you can't get to their front porch because it's gained all. So, I went to the side door and I knocked. >> A younger girl came to the door, probably close to my size. Um, and I asked for it. They they gave me all the we weren't even home. Blah blah blah blah blah. And then she she said, "Okay." I said, "Well, I'm going to call the police." She goes, "Well, you can call Victoria Secret." And I never once said where it was from. I just said a package. >> Okay. What's inside the package, if you don't mind me asking? Um, so >> is it like a whole laundry list of things? >> Oh, yeah. Like um let's see if I chose the um like all of this stuff. It's $400 worth of stuff. >> Okay. >> So, >> okay. >> So, hi. >> Hello. >> How are you? >> I'm all right. Um, so she has a package that got delivered here and she want it back. >> Um, so she has pictures that the package was in fact delivered here and it was sitting right on your >> porch. That's what she said. >> Okay. >> I was in bed till 12:00 this afternoon with my dogs and as you can see they're very vocal >> and they were in bed with me and my husband was not here. Okay. >> So, I believe if the picture shows that the package was here, I believe her. The picture shows that it was here, but I don't do not know anything else. >> All right. Who all who all lives here? >> My daughter, me, and my husband. >> Okay. Would you mind bringing them out also? >> My husband. >> Would you mind bringing them out also? >> Pardon? >> Would you mind bringing them out also so I can explain the situation to them also? >> They were in Rocky River. He went to get her. >> Oh, perfect. There's a Ring doorbell right over there. Perfect. >> The house over there. Hello. Hi. So, does anybody have any idea about this package that got delivered here? Cuz the package 100% got delivered here. We have p She has pictures of it. We know it got delivered here at some point. >> No. When we got home, there was nothing here and she I don't know. Were you up? >> Answer's question. No, I was in bed till now. >> Okay. So, what's going to happen is >> I'm giving you guys the opportunity if you guys did take it to just give it back because if you don't, I'm going to do a theft report and all three of you are going to be listed as suspects. So, what's going to happen? There's a Ring doorbell right over there. So, I'm going to go knock on that door and figure out who came out and picked up that package. And whoever did going to get charged with a theft, okay? And that's $400 worth of stuff. So, either we give it back now, nobody gets in trouble, or I figure out who stole it, and they're going to get charged. That's what we're doing. >> Okay. >> Okay. >> Mhm. >> That's how we're going to handle this. >> If we find it and we know who took it, it will be returned. >> That's not how we're handling this. We find out who took it, they're being charged with theft. Okay? We're not doing this. Oh, you got me. I'm on camera. I took it. I'm going to give it back now. They're going to be charged with theft. I'm I will arrest them for theft. I'm not playing around. Okay. >> So, either give it back now or we're doing I'm listing all three of you as suspects. >> Okay. >> Okay. Driver's license. >> All three of them. >> I have an ID. Is that state ID? Okay. >> Yes, that's fine. >> She has proof that the packages was delivered here. And what time did that get delivered? >> 9:15. >> 9:15. So sometime between 9:15 and basically When did you first get here? >> Um, probably like maybe 12. >> And it was already gone. Correct. >> It was already gone. Yeah, >> it was already gone. >> So between 9:15 and 12. >> Yeah, it was gone. >> Yeah. So >> So she has evidence that it did in fact get delivered here. Um, she tried knocking on the door and got some runaround story about um them like not having it or something. There's a Ring doorbell over there. So, I'm going to try and get uh who came and pick up the package. So, >> so it sounds like these people probably have the package >> most likely. Yeah. >> But they're not like >> they're not fussing up to it. And I even gave them I even gave them the out. I'm like, if you guys just have it, just give it back to them. Nobody gets charged. >> If you don't, I'm going list all three of you as suspects and then we find out who took it. They're being charged with theft. So, we'll see if they come out with the uh the package or not. >> Do you know what the package is? >> Yeah. It's from Victoria's Secret. It's a whole list of things. Like $400 worth of stuff. >> It's a lot of stuff. Yeah. >> These people giving you like a hard time right away. >> I got an attitude from her right away. >> So, you're going to take on? >> Yeah, we'll probably do it. >> Sure. Okay. >> It's pretty straightforward. You know, she ordered the things that actually got delivered here. She came to show up. Was already gone. >> Do you have that information? >> I I didn't get that for you. >> Kind of waiting to see if they come out with the object and be like, "Oh, you know, here it is. >> Your package is on the way out." All right. Did you hear that? >> Yes. Thank you. >> Perfect. >> I'd rather handle it this way. >> I totally agree. >> And then not to uh >> It was open. >> Not to doubt anything, but I'm going to have her check to make sure all the contents are in there. >> She definitely needs to do that. >> Okay. Perfect. >> And if there is anything, I mean, we can compensate if that's what needs to be done. That'll be between you guys at that point. >> I don't >> I was made aware that package. >> Other than that, I don't know. >> Okay. >> We had nothing to do with this. >> All right. Thank you. She's going to make sure that all the stuff is in here. >> Yeah. >> I'm going to go sort of in my truck. >> I'll just I'll stand by just in case. >> Luke took the package. Who took it? >> Yeah, like it was on your porch and you just grabbed it or like a mistake or something. >> Well, grabbed by a mistake by my husband and I'm the one who had it on the floor and I never even noticed the name. I thought it was my daughter. I didn't even look because she does a lot of stuff I don't know about. >> Okay. >> So, we did not do anything shady. I just said here without looking because I know I didn't order it and I just threw it at her because I didn't look when she heard that >> when she heard that David would go >> to jail. No way. Or that I would. No way. We weren't going to go to jail for her. >> All right. She's missing about five things. >> What is she missing? >> I can ask her. They're all different itemized things, so I'll have to >> Did you tell me? >> Well, I think you need to go ask. I suspect whoever has them knows what fire they are. >> Yeah. Okay. >> Because they're all different things. >> Okay. >> So, it I would I would have to verify with her exactly what things are missing >> cuz they're all different. >> If she could tell me. >> Just go check right now. >> Are they going to check? >> Yeah, they're seeing all my good. >> Sorry, I'm not trying to be like no or anything, but >> she said that she has nothing else. You need to call Victoria's Secret on that one. And I believe her because I used to order from Victoria's Secret all the time and the whole order did not come because >> Okay, Patty. >> She needs to check on somebody else. >> She needs to check on them. I used to order the rules and you would get this off. >> So that's what you think is most reasonable? >> Yeah. >> That makes the most sense to you right now? >> Yeah, it does. Because she was scared >> that that she she didn't she didn't steal it? >> No. We're going through all this Victoria send it. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. She's got the the itemized receipt on her phone and in the package. >> Okay. >> She's got the itemized receipt on her phone and from the actual inside the package and there should be 15 things in there. >> I understand that. But I have actually been >> It doesn't matter what they're going by. What? >> Okay. I know that Megan said that she didn't have them. >> Yeah. Let's talk to Megan. Where's Megan at? Why? Why are we even talking to you? >> Okay. >> Is Megan at all? >> What the hell? Get Megan out here. >> Megan, get out of here. >> Doing here. This is stupid. >> Megan order bracelet from >> So, there's like a slip in the bag that has >> 15 things in total. They're all different things. So, it's not like one thing is, you know, listed as quantity one. >> Here's what we're going to do. We're going to give her one chance to get those other items. If not, we're hooking her up and bringing her in. I'm not playing this games. >> That's all. >> Oh, come on. She said >> that was all in there. Victoria had missed seven items in my stuff. >> All right. What's your name? >> Megan. >> All right, Megan. You have one chance to get the stuff. You have five items still missing. Or you missing the stuff, ma'am. What do I do? WHAT ABOUT VICTORIA'S SECRET? I GO TO JAIL FOR A YEAR IN PACKAGE having missing items for Victoria Secret. >> That's why you don't take in packages that don't belong TO YOU. >> I DID IT. I threw it down to her and I didn't look at the name because >> I had to order stuff too. >> I didn't look at your name. I really didn't. >> And now because Victoria Secret's going to miss it. I mean, I had seven items. >> That's fine. >> Basically deny taking it all together. >> Calm down. >> So you denied the whole thing. >> I wasn't even here when it was. >> She made the bag and I made sure and you >> No, wait a minute. David threw it on the floor. I had just got out of my living area >> and she wasn't even here yet and I threw it downstairs. I didn't even look at the name and she I had ordered Victoria, too. >> Wait a minute. >> They didn't even cooperate until you threatened to arrest him. Is that what it looked like? >> That's exactly what happened. >> I didn't want my husband going to jail for something I didn't want. >> Well, somebody's going to go to jail cuz you guys obviously aren't fessing up and giving all the items back. >> I'M GIVING ALL THE ITEMS BACK. EVERYTHING THAT NO, HANG ON. EVERYTHING. >> We've got five more that are missing. >> Okay. I'm telling you, Victoria's Secret is missing that. Not me. >> They've done that for me. >> You can check my underwear drawer. You can check everywhere. I have nothing but Victoria's Secret. >> I get it. If it was like one thing, but five seven items down there, sir. Seven items. >> Sir, I will go down there and look again if you want me to. >> I I sure hope you do, cuz this is your last chance. If you don't come up with those five things, you're being arrested. >> Why am I being arrested? >> Because we're not playing this game. >> She's not playing a game. >> I'm not playing a game. I DON'T I HAVE I have a kid. >> Wait a minute. >> She's got a daughter >> and I have a new job. >> Has nothing TO DO WITH THIS? >> YES, SHE DOES. I DON'T WANT TO GO BACK TO JAIL. I'LL GO TO PRISON. >> WAIT, DID YOU UNDERSTAND FROM VICTORIA SECRET? >> GO downstairs and make sure >> I did I Wait a second. Can I say something? I'm tired of saying stuff. >> This is [ __ ] I would go and I would be here. >> Megan. Hey, stay out here. >> We're still talking to you. You're staying. No way. She's not giving you I'm giving you instructions to stay right here. Do you understand why people are I mean there's Stop. I'm talking you all shut the >> separate Megan. Come down. >> No, I'm not going down with cops. I don't trust you. >> No, you are. >> What? What? WHAT AM I GOING TO DO? STOP. >> COME ON. >> NO. WHAT? Don't touch me. Don't touch ME. WHAT AM I GOING TO DO? >> Shut up. What am I doing? >> Get inside. >> WHAT AM I doing right now? No. WHAT ARE YOU DOING? STOP. IT'S THE WRONG TIME. >> Get inside. >> YOU WERE YELLING AT WHY IS HE TAKING ME TO JAIL? >> WE'RE NOT taking you to jail. You were detaining you right now until we clear this all out. >> Oh my god. >> Stop yelling. >> Stop. >> Please leave me out of hiccups. This better seriously have an inside. Ma'am, I don't have your order. >> Take a deep breath. >> Shut up. Stop. >> I don't have the order. >> Where's the rest of the ship? >> I DON'T KNOW. I MISSED SEVEN ITEMS out of my order. I This is not a first for Victoria Secret. >> Stop. Stop. Stop. No reason why. >> All of us want to leave and get on with our day. That's what we all want. >> Do you want to get my panties off? I mean, Jesus Christ. >> That's what we want. Where's the rest of the >> I don't have them. >> I don't believe you. >> Can I? >> Okay. Thanks a lot, Mom. >> NO. NO. GO CHECK my drawer, MOM. GO CHECK MY DRAWER. TAKE ANY UNDERWEAR. >> What did I do? I just got here. Why are you staring at me? >> I can look at you, can't I? >> 9. I'm sorry. What were the last four? >> 220. >> Huh? What? >> It's nothing to do with this. >> Freezing right now. >> 62y old male. 51. >> Still cold. >> Can you move my hair in my face, please? >> Please. >> Sorry. So, I mean, what I mean, let me So, I just secret my items before. >> I don't care about that. I don't care about that. But I'm let just let him talk. >> I have I'm bipolar and I'm anxiety bad. I am not taking my medicine. Don't want to be in handcuffs. Please, I'll be calm. >> Please. >> We were past that. >> Brown eyes. She doesn't have a license. >> No, it's a valid ID. It's like you've got a warrant for shoplifting out of Georgia. >> It's out of pickup. They don't want you. It's out of the pick. >> They don't want you. Relax. >> 104. >> It's out of the pickup. They don't want you. >> Are you going to be Don't scream. >> I swear if you take the hands off, I'll be cooperative. >> No, we're past that point. Just be detained for a second. It's not a big deal. Just take a breath. >> Yeah. >> So, let me get this straight. There's 15 items that were handed to you or thrown to you. No, they were down there when I got home. >> I understand. >> I was just told to put them away. I didn't I just threw them out. >> Listen, all I'm trying to do right now is honestly, he showed up first. We got to talk to you. I really didn't get to hear the whole thing. I just want to hear a little bit more like >> there. >> That's all I know. I was just really hurt my gone through. >> So, did you like Did you open them up and look through them or something? >> Yeah, she told me to cuz she I guess she thought it was my order. I didn't I was literally not even paying attention. I just opened it and I threw it in the bag. That's it. >> You got plenty of room. What the heck? >> You can do this one right here. >> Yeah, because my bracelet's right there is I made my wrist bigger cuz I've had surgery if you notice. >> Yeah, you got plenty of room in that one. >> These are cutting this part right here. >> Pull on them. >> See, take them off. I'll be I'll be cooperating. >> Don't pull on them. >> Can these things be taken off? Just >> Just relax. Relax. Just like that. You'll be fine. >> I cannot relax with it. You haven't what kind of experience I've had. >> Okay, I know my whole life. >> Just relax. We're just trying to get things figured out. >> I'm not lying to you. Well, >> what? What? >> So, when you were looking through all those items and putting them away, like you said, >> Yeah. >> did any of them did it all seem like stuff that you ordered or >> I didn't even pay attention. I was just trying to I was doing what she told me to clean the basement cuz I had so much [ __ ] I just moved back in for my boyfriend's. We broke up. >> Would you just like grab them all and just Yeah. Through? Yeah, pretty much. >> Okay. >> So, you're sure there wasn't a mistake? >> Can I go double check my drawer? Cuz she doesn't know what she's looking for. I could probably tell which if anything is in there. >> I thought But you just said for sure nothing in there. >> I can go double check cuz I shoved them in there. You don't tell how deep that is antique drawer. You how deep that thing goes. >> Yeah. I don't know about >> Can I please go double check? >> One second cuz I don't know what he was talking about with your mom. So, I don't know if you know they found him or didn't find him. I don't know what's going on with that. So, I want >> just trying to figure this out together. >> Wait, wait, wait. What? >> He was just talking to your mom, the other officer down there. >> Yeah. About what? >> I don't I don't know what he had to say about this, but he'll stand with you. I'll ask him about it. So it's like and I would have never got it back if you guys didn't come here. So she would have freely taken my stuff. >> Right. So yeah. So your options here is again we we can go with theft and the best evidence we have is that she took those items or if you think you've got most of it and you could get you know reach out to Victoria's Secret explain the situation and if they would replace it. I have no idea if they would do that or or whatever. But I'm just from if I'm in your shoes those are my two directions I can go. >> Uh you just got to tell us what you want to do so we know what to do next. >> And my conscious too because this girl is troubled. My question to you is um do you order stuff from Victoria Secret frequently? >> I mean I Yeah. >> How often do you have problems with them not fulfilling order? >> Never. I mean I'm an avid online shopper. So you know I mean I you don't usually there's not stuff missing. >> So that's why I >> Yeah. That's why that's why I said to her, you know, one thing missing I can kind of understand one thing missing, but five, >> right? I mean they're a pretty legit company. So, you know, they have checks and balances. So, you know, >> Yeah. I mean, I think that she >> took my stuff and that she was going to keep it, obviously. I mean, I said, "I'm going to call cops." >> Mhm. >> And they I mean, there's no harm. You open up all that stuff and you you don't realize what you order. >> So, so she did it. >> Yeah. I want to test this. >> Just stay safe. >> Is she running me? >> I don't know. Just take a breath. >> Just take a breath. We'll figure it out. >> I promise you, Victoria Secret has missed seven eyes my [ __ ] before. I'm not lying over this. >> Well, that's what we're figuring out, right? >> I don't want to go back. I'll go to prison. I'm on felony probation. >> Oh, I see. But >> not Well, no, I'm actually I think I'm off that. >> Yeah, I don't think >> Yeah. Yeah, I'm off. >> You're not probation. >> Oh, yeah. Yeah, I'm not I'm so used to I'm so used to being on probation. That's so bad. >> What's good? >> My whole life. >> All right. She's uh coming in. All right. >> You're coming in for theft. There's nobody here. >> All right. >> H >> You're coming in FOR THE >> WAIT, NO. MOM. MOM. MOM, GO CHECK MY DRAWER. GO CHECK MY DRAWER. >> NO. CAN I GO CHECK my drawer? I can I promise you I can probably find him. >> No. You remember where it's at now? >> NO. I PROMISE. I PROBABLY I SAID THEY'RE DEEP in Can you take this out? >> Let's go. No, you're staying in the cuffs. Let's go. >> Can you go with her? >> Mom, can she go with me? >> Let's go. W go. How about that? It'll be a big family party. Come on. >> Stop yelling. >> Please. Please. >> No. I asked him if I could go in there. >> Same volume. She's talking. >> Okay. Calm down. >> He wants to take Can you let go of me? >> No, we can't. >> They want to take me in for a Can you let go of my arm, please, so I can look? Can you open >> the antique blackmail? That's not mine. >> Mom, you didn't look. Cuz there's not. There's stuff in here that's not mine. >> Where? >> Right here. That one not mine. >> This one's not mine. >> I didn't know that. >> Yeah. >> You didn't look all the way. This is not mine. Wait, hang on. >> I have a pair like this. >> That's >> No, that's brand new. Mom, you didn't look at this. >> No, I didn't see them. Sorry. >> She didn't look at that. >> And hang on. Open this drawer. I threw some in here. This one. Oh, you got to open both handles. They're antique. It's antique. Close this one. Pop one. >> Is this here? >> Yeah. That's mine. Mom, I got that. That's a um from a thrift store. >> Sorry. >> Mom, I told you I threw them in between shirts. Look. >> Wait a minute. >> Right there. No, there's one right here. I told you I I You didn't check. She normally checks to see how I fold and everything. And honestly, I just threw them in there. Right. The shirts, Mom. I You didn't check. >> Why didn't you say that? Because I told you I threw them in between shirts so you wouldn't yell at me and you told me. No. Mom, >> these are shirts. >> Mom, it's towards the top where I pointed at >> here. You're being an airhead right there. >> You know what? >> I told you I threw stuff in. >> Seconds to do this. Now you >> see what I'm saying? She yells at me for everything. >> Now you won't go to jail if you have just done it in the beginning. She won't go now, right? >> There five five more items. Is that what we got there? >> Four. >> Is there something else? >> No, there's nothing else. I swear to God. Here. Check in here. Just one item missing. >> What? How do you know what she's missing? What is she missing exactly? Does she have the order? >> Cuz I don't know what I'm looking for here. >> Let's do it the easy way. What doesn't belong to you? >> That's all my underwear. Mine. My underwear now. >> That's all my underwear now. So, what else is she missing? She doesn't even know. Shh. >> Quit cussing at that. >> You feel me? She doesn't have her number. >> Megan, come. >> You are in no position to me like that. >> No, I'm just saying I'm not at you. It's like two of you. How do you see my frustrated? >> Both just stop talking. Don't get your finger off me. >> Stop. >> Stop. >> God. I mean, are you guys serious? >> We're just like, >> she's bipolar. Sorry. There's four items here. >> Anxiety. There's one missing. He wants >> a shirt or something. >> No. >> This No, those are all over. That's it. >> There's four items. >> There's no other items here. >> No. >> No. >> Check my drawers. Check them. I I told you all I wear is Victoria's Secret. >> She was lying. >> Let's go back upstairs. Let's >> We'll go just Yeah. >> Oh, can you not do that? >> Wait. Yeah, it's off. >> It doesn't >> He even loosened them for you. >> No, he didn't. >> Well, there's You can put your whole finger. >> Oh, no. My wrist is bad, though. I have a broken bra. >> Wait for me. >> She didn't look all the way to >> Jordan. And my bra is even Victoria's Secret. >> This way. This way. I >> I didn't know. >> Why didn't there >> I didn't know there >> I told her to look there. >> Go before. >> I'll stay with her. You go. >> Can I come out? >> I'd rather not. >> No, no, no. She'll keep me. I'll keep her calm. >> I'd rather not. >> She would keep me calm. >> Yeah. Mom, thank you. Y or that's going to get you problem. Okay. What was that for? >> You're being detained right now. I don't want you having access to your phone. >> I was just sh >> Why am I being taken for this? I just got home with this [ __ ] >> You're not in >> This is not fair. Mom, >> stop. The neighbors come here. You don't >> That's all you worried about instead of your daughter going to [ __ ] jail over this. >> Megan, you're not in a position to be talking this way. Will you please stop? You're probably not going to get in any trouble now because you gave them everything and one thing's missing from that. >> You don't even know what's missing. Shh. >> Stop. I don't stop right now. Pretend like you get. >> Um, so there's four items here. >> Okay. >> We look She swears up and down that that's the only thing. So what else were you missing? >> So it would So there was five additional items, I think. So yeah. So, she probably has them on cuz if they're all the underwear, >> right? >> Which I'm not gonna $5. I'm not going to. >> So, are you >> I mean, I I I still think that she should get in trouble. >> I mean, she took it. >> She took it. You know, I I just, you know, that's that's [ __ ] to me, people. That's a lot of money that she was just going to take. And there's no way you could just Oh, I thought they were mine. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> So, since you have all the items back now, well, except for the one, >> which Yeah. >> You still want to do the prosecution then? >> Why? I was >> I can't force you to go one. >> I know that, but I mean, she she was going to steal my stuff, though. >> Yeah. I you know I mean I just don't think that people should get away with that. I don't know. I don't steal people's [ __ ] >> Okay. Um so yes then we kind of need a different yes >> and I gave it to I nicely >> she was not giving it back. >> All right. So, she still wants to desire prosecution for the one item that's missing. >> Are you kidding me? I don't have it. >> Listen, >> the thing is we had to go through all of this just to even get the package back. >> I told her where to check. >> No, I told her where to check. No, don't take me in. >> No, we don't let go. I love it. >> Well, we're passing this way. >> What if I help? >> What if I paid for No. Hey, let go. What is going to happen? >> Is this the underwear you gave me, Mom? >> For how long, >> ma'am? Is it Ask her if it's a pink pair under Ask her if it's a pink pair underwear. Ask her. I'M WEARING THEM. OH MY. >> Ask her if it's a pink pair of underwear. I'll take them off. >> She just wore them. >> No. Mom, you gave me a pink pair underwear. Does that come out of the package? >> Did it? >> Yeah. >> Yeah, I did. Ma'am, I have them. >> Can you please tell her? >> Ma'am, I have them. CAN YOU PLEASE I DON'T HAVE ANY shoes on my mom. Mom, I don't have Can you please tell her? >> Yeah, bring some damn shoes. >> Can you please tell her? What am I being taken to jail for? >> Why? >> Which side? >> Everyone, huh? >> My mom put him in my room. Ow. You're sitting on MY BUTT. MOM, >> TAKE A SEAT. >> OH MY GOD. Help me. Mom, can you please tell that lady, my mom gave me the pink pair of underwear? Ask her if those are it. Can you ask her before you take me in? >> Can you read? >> Sir, can you say >> the neighbor volunteered to call Victoria's Secret before the victim ever mentioned the company's name under Illinois versus Gates? That unprompted disclosure from someone claiming no contact with the package is exactly the corroborating fact that tips the totality of circumstances toward probable cause. Delivery photographs plus that unprompted disclosure gave the officer enough to approach under Terry versus Ohio. Reasonable articulable suspicion requires only specific articulable facts pointing toward criminal conduct, not certainty, and both conditions were satisfied before the first knock. A voluntary return offer made before formal detention is not a legal commitment, but it is a documented record of non-ooperation. Refusing it supports the willfulness element under Ohio Revised Code section 2913.02 02 and cuts against any later claim that the retention was an honest mistake. Miranda does not attach to a non-custodial investigative encounter, which means every denial, every contradiction, and the admission that the package was opened and his contents distributed, all of it made before handcuffs went on is fully admissible and goes straight to the prosecution's case. The moment physical restraints were applied, Miranda attached, requiring advisement of the right to remain silent and the right to counsel before custodial questioning begins. Stanbury versus California sets the test objectively. Whether a reasonable person in that position would feel free to leave, which handcuffs answered definitively. Questioning about missing items continued after restraints went on, and no Miranda advisement came first. Any statement produced by custodial interrogation without prior advisement is suppressible, and this is the first motion a defense attorney files. The bedroom search stands on solid constitutional ground because the subject initiated it herself, asking repeatedly while restrained to check her own drawer. Schneckloth versus Bamante holds voluntary self-initiated consent is legally sufficient. Georgia versus Randolph does not apply because no coccupant raised an objection. Ohio's theft statute requires the prosecution to prove knowing control over another's property. She told officers her drawer was empty and four items came out of it minutes later. Opening a package, distributing its contents into personal drawers, and then denying all of it is not confusion. It is the element. Under Ohio Revised Code section 2913.02, theft of property valued below $1,000 is petty theft. A misdemeanor of the first degree, which means county jail, not state prison, and $400 falls well below that threshold. The statutory ceiling is 180 days county jail and a fine of up to $1,000 with courts routinely ordering restitution for any unreovered merchandise on top three separate financial obligations running simultaneously. A firsttime offender on this charge in Ohio typically gets probation or a fine, not active jail time. But this subject had an outstanding shoplifting warrant and documented felony probation history, which eliminates first offender diversion programs and gives the sentencing judge real grounds for active time. if she was still on felony probation when this arrest happened, a question she could not answer on camera. This conviction triggers a separate revocation proceeding carrying the original felony sentence, meaning state prison measured in years, not a county misdemeanor, measured in days. The lead officer earns a B+. The voluntary return offer, the Ring doorbell reference, and background checks on all three occupants reflect methodical investigative work. One procedural vulnerability exists, and it came exactly at the moment restraints went on. Continuing to question Megan about missing items after handcuffs went on without Miranda advisement is that vulnerability it did not need to exist and a competent defense attorney will make sure it gets noticed. Megan receives a D. Every denial she made is directly contradicted by physical evidence found in her room and cooperation came only after an explicit arrest threat. Her own request to check the drawer she insisted was empty produced the evidence that confirmed the charge. The victim earns an A minus delivery photographs, an itemized receipt, a prior attempt at direct resolution, and she never disclosed the package's origin before knocking on that door. That single restraint turned the neighbor's spontaneous disclosure into the most damning circumstantial detail in the encounter. The first denial made everything that followed inevitable. Returning the package at the door cost nothing and would have closed the matter in 2 minutes. Every refusal after that built the prosecution's case. All of it on camera. All of it admissible. Silence carries no legal cost and cannot be used as evidence of guilt. Yet every explanation the subject gave became part of the record against her and her offer to search her own drawer voluntary and irrevocable under Schneckloth versus Bamante produced the evidence that sealed it. Let us know if there is an interaction or legal topic you would like us to discuss in the comments below. Thank you for watching and don't forget to check out our channel for more police interaction and courtroom content.