I got beat up so I'm a little bit like you know disheveled I'm hungry I have to pee I didn't brush my teeth I have my period I just wanna go home OK unfortunately I had a hamburger I had some smart food popcorn but I gave it to a little girl with red hair and a flower dress by seat 1 11 and 17th hole of the Bear Trap I ate a you drinking it all I had a beer at 10 o'clock this morning I didn't even finish it was a Corona I had it at Big Rockers in Redondo Beach now you got me mad OK you gave me a fake ID that's illegal on March 3rd, 2024 Palm Beach Gardens police responded to PGA National Resort following a theft and identity fraud complaint the interaction raises three critical legal issues the lawfulness of the detention Miranda timing and proportionality of force your car so you see where you turn right to go into the gym instead you're gonna turn left where you go on the Uber lot it's gonna be there right next to a Jupiter police car okay am I going to the airport right now I don't know it's your car I got a ticket to the airport so you alright yeah I'm fine can I see your keys what can I just see him no I'm good I'm a police officer OK security guard OK let me see your ticket let me see your keys my keys my keys let me see your keys OK let's walk over there OK are you gonna take me huh are you gonna take me to my car no find out what's wrong with you there's nothing wrong with me OK I just wanna make sure there's something wrong with you my name is my name is Maya say it again my name is Maya OK what's going on so what's going on so see I got beat up so I'm a little bit like you know disheveled I'm hungry I have to pee I didn't brush my teeth I have my period I just wanna go home OK where's home well I'm gonna be going to Georgia and then I'm gonna be I got married in December where you going right now where's your plan to go I'm going to my car and I'm gonna go get something something at Burger King chicken tenders okay and then where are you going I'm gonna be going to my mom's in Georgia in Georgia so yeah how you gonna get there you driving yeah you drive to Georgia yeah I drive to Georgia all the time don't you no but you don't drive you're a police officer you're a cruise officer are you okay ma'am yeah I'm fine just two seconds ago you said you're going to the airport no I said I have tickets to go to the airport on Wednesday so I'm gonna go to the airport on Wednesday listen I just had a terrible time how are you going to the airport on Wednesday we're going to Georgia today well it's today Sunday takes eight hours to get to Georgia I'm gonna go visit my mother she just opened a new hair salon and then I'm gonna drive to the airport which is in Georgia do you have an idea on you ma'am no do you have anything with your name on it yeah I have a marriage certificate that would be great come on I got did you ever get you don't have an ID you're gonna drive huh are you gonna drive with no ID uh I'll find it it's in my bag did you get ever get new shoes and never like try them out before you wore them don't do it I'm wearing it I got this okay what is that I don't know what that is yeah we're at the resort excuse you I only have one copy so don't lose it I'm gonna be right here I'm not going anywhere here's my ticket for the airport you have a ticket for the airport no why it's not your business where I'm going my concern is right now is if you're okay to drive okay okay and if you want to give a breathalyzer no no I don't think you're drunk I think something else might be wrong with you oh well you're wrong stop give me my marriage certificate stop give me my marriage certificate stop okay give me my marriage certificate no no no listen listen to what I'm telling you okay right now I'm trying to make sure that you're okay right this is not an arrestable offense it's the difference between I don't know where you're from but you're in the state of Florida so it's called the Baker Act which means I'll take you to a mental here ready OK here and I'll make sure you're cleared for the hospital been there what does that what does that have to do with been there OK what does that have to do with what I'm talking about nothing give me my paper back what is your name Maya Maya what read it it's on there I got married December 6 2023 I'm a little bit about Maya where does it say anything about Maya huh it's my marriage certificate what are you talking about where does it say Maya flip it over do you want to see my wedding invitations oh right here look that's you Mya Daniels okay I don't you live in Las Vegas you're from Las Vegas well I got married there so don't judge okay alright just give me one second I just wanna make sure you're good make sure you have a valid license and stuff okay okay alright you might want to check for Corina Quill she got a license last name Daniels Common Spelling first name Mike Alpha Yankee Alpha middle initial Mike date of birth 3 8 am 1998 white female she might be out of either Las Vegas or said Georgia I have the other key I can go without your key awesome can I make your certificate I don't care how many keys huh I don't care how many keys you have but can I make sure that you're okay to drive okay cause I am very concerned about you that's nice okay I'm concerned for you okay I'm very concerned about you perfect okay cause you're not making sense yes I am a lot of things can you come over here and witness the fact that I'm making sense please that's b*llsh*t okay no I didn't I absolutely did not and I'm recording this on my phone so you wanna play it back well listen I didn't say anything I said to the officer can you take me and he said no so please don't tell me what I said because I'm not an officer I have a CPR certification I'm a medical professional thank you what do you do for a living say a medical professional well right now I'm out of work if you need to know OK what is that what is that ID mean what is the badge mean what is what is it it's for the haunted classic what is it just a guest pass to get in yeah OK what what does your badge mean it means you're here to protect and serve right if you don't know then you need to take your oath again listen do you wanna hurt yourself nope never you're gonna hurt yourself not one day in my life hell no I come with a price I'm at PGA National what city are you in Palm Beach Gardens unfortunately I had a hamburger I had some smart food popcorn but I gave it to a little girl with red hair and a flower dress by seat 1 11 and 17th hole of the Bear Trap I ate a you drinking it all I had a beer at 10 o'clock this morning I didn't even finish it was a Corona I had it at Big Rockers in Redondo Beach God what state are you from what state are you from originally New Jersey try New Jersey please you have an ID in New Jersey I have a Florida ID now he's not there I have a license right there okay do you have an ID with your name on it let me see an ID with your name on it can you not show that guy behind you OK yeah you get 22 out that guy's behind you $65 you could leave let me get you a deal you're real right listen I'm a police officer give me your ID 65 deal number listen I don't care now now you got me mad OK you gave me a fake ID that's illegal you didn't give me any ID you did I gave you a marriage certificate that's the same thing I gave you a marriage certificate and you told me your name was that that is a fake ID sure yeah these are the bags they gave me turn around hey hey hey hey turn around turn around don't throw me down don't throw me down don't throw me down don't throw me down don't throw me down turn around don't throw me down please turn around don't throw me down right now alright turn around put your hands on your back OK do it now turn around please don't hurt me turn around please don't hurt me turn around and put your hands on your back please don't hurt me please don't hurt me there you go please don't hurt me I have a broken thumb please don't hurt me help please help please help stop resisting I'm not stop resisting please help mom mom mom please help please help please help officer please help my name is Maya alright Maya just calm down take her take her bag then my thumb please take this bag they gave me the bag listen officer they gave me the bag stop it stop it they gave me the bag we're at the resort stop it we're done just hang out right here okay no we're done I don't care we have to do ow ow ow ow just take this backpack off for a second wait for the they gave me the bags she's giving me fake IDS just one of it I have real ID you have stop it stop it stop it stop touching me don't touch me stop touching OK we're gonna do that in a second they gave this to me they gave this to me aw you're hurting my arm then stop moving and just hang out we're done I'll be hurting my shoulder though we're done stop it we're done you have my real ID though okay well we're done just hang out right there buddy we're right on the ramp we're right on the ramp in the furniture alright well so I'm here um you're on my shoulder can I stretch my leg please what's going on hey listen he has a long story let's get her up and take off yeah well she's stealing all the people's bags no I didn't sir they gave me the bag out I'll get up I'll get up I'll get up 1 2 OK ow ow my arm take this backpack off of me one two five six and then make your way over here I'll get up hold on one yeah wait one get on up come on we're gonna get a part of you come on get up there you go take this backpack off it's letting me you're under arrest let's go okay hold on a second no we're done 15 yeah wait listen where's Karina Cook's ID where's my ID we're done I know you're under arrest so you please do not resist OK take this backpack off me it's not mine of course it's not yours that's why you're under arrest no this is not my backpack that's great that's mine we have to go that's mine let's go aw aw aw aw you're hurting my arm then start walking aw start walking we're done help me are you a sheriff no they have my ID what does that mean I didn't steal yeah right I swear to Christ for my mother okay I repeat this and you park your car over there right it's told you by the way we told your car not my car you didn't call my car papa I have the phone number okay no his name is Mike oh wait one second for me we're right here the car is almost here I'm gonna piss myself oh that's too bad listen I'm not going anywhere with you guys you guys locked me up and beat me up wait let's do this right put it right here put it right here OK yeah let's get his stuff ah my thumb is broke one one four five 0 2 ah I'm not resisting five o'clock in the morning try try to take a deep breath take a deep breath OK thank you sir you can keep your mask on here pass through this and you'll be escorted to the patrol unit for here you go she's gone yes she's definitely gone yes the initial stop satisfies the reasonable articulable suspicion standard established in Terry versus Ohio in 1968 a specific complaint from identifiable resort personnel placing a named suspect in possession of another guest's property clears that threshold Florida versus JL decided in 2000 confirms that tips from identifiable sources carry significantly greater constitutional weight than anonymous complaints the officer's citation of the Baker Act Florida Statute Section 3 94.4 67 warrants recognition that statute authorizes involuntary psychiatric examination when a person appears mentally ill and unable to ensure their own safety the subject displayed disorientation contradictory statements about her location and plans and claimed a recent physical assault those observable indicators were sufficient to support a Baker Act hold the decision to proceed with criminal arrest instead was lawful but the Baker Act option was real relevant and correctly identified the most consequential legal issue in this footage is Miranda timing Miranda versus Arizona decided in 1966 requires that custodial interrogation be preceded by a rights advisement the subject was placed in handcuffs at approximately 8 minutes 5 seconds under burkimer versus Mccarty decided in 1984 custody for Miranda purposes attaches when freedom of movement is restrained to the degree associated with formal arrest handcuffing meets that standard the first Miranda warning was not administered until 15 minutes 21 seconds seven minutes and 16 seconds after handcuffing while an active pat down was simultaneously underway under Rhode Island versus Innis decided in 1980 interrogation includes any officer questioning reasonably likely to elicit an incriminating response questions about ownership of allegedly stolen bags meet that definition precisely any statements obtained during that seven minute window are subject to suppression under map versus Ohio's exclusionary rule a second complete advisement was read at 15 minutes 53 seconds the subject confirmed understanding and proceeded to answer questions under Burgess versus Thompkins decided in 2010 that conduct constitutes a voluntary waiver of the right to silence force analysis under Graham versus Conner decided in 1989 requires objective reasonableness based on circumstances known to the officer at the moment of application the subject was suspected of a felony was non compliant with lawful commands and actively resisted handcuffing officers did not deploy less lethal tools force remained at the soft and hard empty hand control level throughout that progression is consistent with the use of force continuum and raise no constitutional concern there's a what where was it yeah we ran it already supposedly you look at me who's gonna take this face we're done alright you give me a fake ID that don't belong to you oh yeah so let me find out who bought practice Bill I won't be able to get it off yeah we'll just wait till the yeah I want my mom stop acting up man okay I need to see the water and I wanna pee you OK I need to see the backpack for real yeah I got it ma'am you can't do it with the cuffs on so just stand by for a second you can't get away with this stand by no I won't that's one of those look at the fines is he hey how you doing we're gonna take off listen listen to me when I'm not in this cap just take the cup up yeah I didn't know she was your hair all done looking good looking fancy if you act up I'm gonna take you if you act out like there's four officers here don't even try oh I hope you don't resist OK you told me I was resisting before and I would never OK my dad was a police officer alright my grandfather's Judge Ramsay ah oh you didn't get all the way through there you go that one for the mama all right for camarón you have a Spanish no I don't speak Spanish I'm American I'm here hi good morning I'll bring it back is there a woman this is an incident for this is a woman hello Yay what's your name cardio what's this Garyo Garyo my name is Carina my birthday is 12 13 73 alright I've never intended on hurting anyone or myself my Social Security number my Social Security number my Social Security number your back do it again do it again baby yep do it again do it again there you go huh I have something in my pocket hold on hold on this is technical god we're just trying to steal his bags my name is I'm sorry Maya what's the problem congratulations on your money I got a computer to confront so this is not yeah oh hey hold on hold on I'm gonna find an ID so see what this is what are you doing what's up I have a receipt that I need just hang out right there buddy what do you need OK go relax OK go relax what's going on with her she's the victim of the theft OK just take her over there just take her over there by the stairs sorry Maya OK don't touch her don't touch her I have a lighter be careful okay so I don't know how to use it could be a lighter or knife there's a knife knife it's orange I have a problem with you guys that advise the 14 of the golfer trying to steal bags relax relax okay may god another day bro another day may god protect and keep you oh hey Romero they gave me the bags I didn't steal them Le Beau brought them OK OK alright relax your buddy listen Le Beau brought them to me from the butcher shop hey hey Romero the ball brought them to me from Arrow go to the butcher shop 23 I'm returning all the stuff I gotta figure out what what's what just listen yeah my thing my the brown bag is mine OK that's it stop it I don't care just be quiet that's it it's not funny all right let her up in the back I'll do the front the bowgate from the butcher shop came in the back wonderful face forward okay face forward you are no I don't know what forward is look that way there you go you have anything in your bra anything only food not this one listen turn around turn around face that way face that way there you go stay that way until I tell you otherwise OK OK I'm gonna read you something while she's doing that OK you have the right to remain silent and answer any questions any statement you make must be freely and voluntarily given you have the right to the presence and representation of a lawyer of your choice before you make any statement during any questioning that's my house please if you cannot afford a lawyer you're entitled to the presence of representation of a court appointed lawyer before you make any statement during any questioning if at any time during the interview do not wish to answer any questions you are privileged to remain silent I can make no threats or promises to induce you to make a statement this will be of your own free will any statement can and will be used against you in court law you understand what I read to you today you understand your rights read them one more time OK you have the right to remain silent and answer any questions any statement you make must be freely and voluntarily given you have the right to the presence of representation of a lawyer of your choice before you make any statement during any questioning if at any time if you cannot afford a lawyer you are entitled to the presence and representation of a court appointed lawyer before you make any statement during any questioning perfect if at any time during the interview you do not wish to answer any questions you are privileged to remain silent okay I can make no threats or promises to induce you to make a statement this must be of your own free will okay any statement can and will be used against you in a court of law you understand what I read to you today yeah okay with that in mind is that Rolex yours yes you bought it yes what type of Rolex is it it's a custom Rolex I bought it with Michael Marinelli the receipts in my safe it's I don't know it's a blue face Rolex I ordered for my daughter from Mayer's and bought it from the phone Michael Marinelli was my boyfriend and I have the receipt in my safe this is the lady from the car relax relax let me do I gotta do her shoes let me do her shoes can you take these shoes off cause they hurt hold on just take off your watch when you get a chance my watch yeah oh my dad gave it to me he's dead listen are all four bags hers this one is no put that no no there's a bunch of put it because that's not that's a separate yes are all four bags yours the you wanna come with me one two yes the three up here not the not the you know about the truth yes okay um so explain to me what happened from the beginning so basically my husband was playing golf today he was one of the last groups to finish on 18 we're trying to make a flight so I went to our rental car I took the rental car or I took his travel case out of the rental car I brought it into the locker room waited for him there as soon as he got there I said do you want me to go pick up my bags from bag drop so we had what time did you drop them off 10:30 this morning this morning 10:30 this morning and we dropped off uh one two three four five six bags in total um and then I pulled up to valet and I asked the guy if he could just pull the car around so I could go pick up my bags from bag drop I stepped out of the car I saw this lady holding my two suitcases my bag and my backpack completely coincidentally and um the white bag the white bag how much do you value the contents in it and your glasses are in it or your clothes is in it I would say probably probably around $2,000 in the white bag and how about in the green one which green one the little green the the little one uh huh uh probably around $700 and how about the other one uh this the suitcase one yeah that one probably around $1,000 and this bag destination I know you have personal paperwork in there too I do have but besides the personal paperwork is there any watches any jewelry there's no jewelry there's anything like that there's a nice like there's a coach bag in there there's a iPad and there's a laptop as well okay um there's a good amount of money and stuff yeah yeah um grand theft under Florida Statute section 8 12.0 14 requires property value exceeding $750 the victim estimated approximately $3,700 in total contents clearing the third degree felony threshold by a substantial margin identity fraud under Florida Statute section 8 17.5 68 requires willful unauthorized use of another person's identifying information possession of another person's identification documents within the context of a bag theft provides sufficient probable cause for both charges as filed the subject received 5 years probation consistent with Florida sentencing practices for first time non violent felony property offenses under Florida Statute Section 9 21.00 26 the officer receives a B+ the welfare first approach and accurate Baker Act identification reflect training well above the baseline force was proportionate to resistance encountered the arrest was legally justified the Miranda timing failure seven minutes of post custody questioning without a prior rights advisement is the sole basis for withholding a higher grade it created a suppression risk that was entirely avoidable the subject receives a d the underlying criminal conduct drove the outcome from a rights assertion standpoint providing seven or more minutes of statements without invoking the Fifth Amendment right to silence was legally self defeating that remains true regardless of the merits of any underlying defense the department receives a B strong Baker Act awareness proper pat down protocols and measured scene management reflect adequate institutional training across this interaction if the Miranda timing reflects a systemic practice rather than individual error it is the department's single most actionable corrective priority this wasn't improvised let's examine what the law authorizes and what it doesn't three lessons that he emerged from this footage first Miranda is a before requirement read rights at the moment of handcuffing before any further questioning proceeds second the Baker Act is a legitimate law enforcement tool not a secondary option an equal alternative wherever mental state is in genuine question third from the moment of custody silence is the most protective exercise of the Fifth Amendment available to any detained person regardless of innocence or guilt let us know if there is an interaction or legal topic that you would like us to discuss in the comments below thank you for watching and don't forget to subscribe to our channel for more content on police court interactions