the agent went to close the door and there was one that was sitting on the flight and was refusing even to move right now I can press charges for you trespassing you went I'm not trespassing I have a lawyer I'm going home like everybody else if I don't go home nobody go home Miami International July 2022 denied at the gate she walks onto the plane anyway her defense on camera I paid for my ticket a ticket it turns out is not what she thinks it is I'm sorry I'm sorry I just I just walk in like just like you guys I walk in with you guys for what I understood I just rush in um the agent went to close the door and there was one that was sitting on the flight and was refusing even to move Philippe is uh Stephanie uh Stephanie inside they stepped out already how's how's the G14 she's inside she's inside she's inside the plane I just let me just go in take cause I think there was one that was refusing um getting out and there's plenty of people outside let the supervisor go and let him know but we have to listen because it's our first after war and if not we have to complain everybody everybody first we start with the person in front of first we start with the person in front what's he oh thank you she's gonna go in front who's the first the she's gonna in the back on the left thank you right now I can press charges for you trespassing you went I'm not trespassing I have a lawyer I just let you know right now that police officers are here we're gonna ask you to voluntarily walk out of the plane if not we're gonna ask everybody we're gonna ask I understand I understand but you will not bored when we close the door you went through the door when there was no action at the moment ma'am at the moment ma'am let's talk to you outside let's come outside right now if you don't get out right now OK hold on let me get everybody out alright OK we'll get everybody out I'm bored like everybody else and I paid for my ticket like everybody else alright let's go let's go to the jet bridge so we can talk what do you mean no come over here we're gonna talk about alright I'm going home like everybody else if I don't go home nobody go home yes cool OK alright I never did nothing like what I paid for my ticket like everybody else ma'am we need to talk to you let's go outside no I don't have to talk to y'all OK you're gonna make it worse y'all can send me a picture in the mail you okay y'all can literally send me something in the mail what whatever I pay for a ticket I pay for a ticket like everybody else let's go everybody has to get on the plane after me there's people that got on the plane after me there's people that got on the plane after me well they're gonna be charges against you for trespassing OK yep so thank you I'm in and guess what i'mma beat the case cause I'm not trespassing ladies and gentlemen unfortunately we're gonna have to be everybody what my name is you should know that I was just asking and waiting in the boarding area ask the ask the lady on the flight I say something may I say something to you there's nothing to say may I say something there's nothing to say will you listen to what I have to say now will you listen like that will you listen what I have to say stand over here make sure you get your belongings make sure you have your body fast in your hands while we're gonna stab you both from here we will do this as soon as possible all right let's go I apologize for the delay and I apologize for that I paid for my ticket like everybody else well y'all come from that fast what's that y'all come from that fast we're around there's a lot of people here not to the board get your ass off the plane get off ma'am don't instigate her please guys don't instigate her cause then we gotta deal with her hey they never refuse me I was already on the plane I'm refusing you now now after the fact though but that's after the fact you can't do that after the fact so no everybody going we all going home late oh well no I can't I can't cause they should have just took off let's go let's go let's do it fast why you guys waiting for let's go okay let's go let's move my boarding pass is the same flight as everybody else what do you mean the f*ck that's dumb as they just wanna have an attitude cause they're miserable they're miserable with their life there's nothing for you to say what is there for you to say like I said y'all wanna make my life hard make everybody else life hard I wanna go home I don't even live here that's weird as y'all weird but y'all mad cause y'all really can't do anything besides make everybody get off and everybody get back on gotta wait till everybody get off New New Hope Lane it's cool I already sent my dad the information yeah everybody getting off y'all too you can go let's go you go in front of me and she gonna go behind me and she's going behind me no that's mine clearly alright let's go you're not going behind me though ma'am let's go you can go and I will go behind you you're not walking behind me period ma'am I don't trust you I don't trust yes please record thank you I give you this um my Instagram is so send it to me so I can send it to my daddy that's your only bag cause they're definitely not walking behind me the f*ck yeah make sure y'all Instagram oh my god hurry up send me the videos so I can send them to my dad they already have my ID I got on the plane we need your ID no you don't need my ID that's OK I'm giving you a direct order to walk over there OK don't make it worse don't make it worse they're making it worse for them that's illegal I didn't do sh*t I have a ticket like everybody else everybody here is out and I have a ticket like everybody else what do you mean three separate layers of law converge on a commercial aircraft first federal aviation law under Title 49 of the United States Code section 44,902 subsection b an air carrier may refuse transport to any passenger the carrier decides is or might be inimical to safety The 2nd Circuit in Williams versus Trans World Airlines established that such decisions are reviewed only for arbitrariness a boarding pass therefore is not an entitlement it is a conditional offer revocable at the airline's discretion second federal criminal law Title 49 Section 46,504 makes assault or intimidation of a flight crew member a federal felony carrying up to 20 years imprisonment threats to compel a captain to depart if proven squarely implicate this statute third state trespass law under Florida Statutes section 810.08 an aircraft qualifies as a conveyance once the carrier withdraws authorization and warns the occupant to depart continued presence constitutes criminal trespass refusal to obey the subsequent lawful order of an officer adds liability under Florida Statutes section 843.02 for resisting without violence can somebody record this can somebody record this what is you doing what is you doing it is not necessary y'all not necessary what the hell I have a ticket for this flight and y'all trying to take me off the flight it's no longer valid what do you mean it's not valid but everybody else is valid I'm not gonna fight we're gonna have to wait hold on let's go relax we're gonna take your property I'm relaxed you're grabbing me you're not grabbing your property I'm relaxed you're grabbing me what do you mean because why is he grabbing me and I'm relaxed like I said he grabbing me that's illegal as f*ck though it's cool cause I don't mind suing nobody I'm going to Miami police that's why he's shaking his head he over y'all he's shaking his head and I'm on camera at the airport it's illegal as I have a ticket and y'all mad because I have literally the plane got stopped cause I have a ticket to no my I'll get you I'll get you I'll get you uh what do you need she goes to jail for that once you refuse to get off the the airplane that's trespassing get me the info I will 2 6 9 2 7 4 2 3 5 text my dad and tell him see look at them they drag now they wanna drag 2 6 9 2 7 4 2 6 9 2 7 4 no over here 2 3 5 door 19 you can exit out just exit out exit exit out what's up make sure y'all right there yeah yeah I know turn around relax no that's illegal I just went through TSA alright stay right there stay right there hey they're trying to beat me 2 6 2 3 5 5 it's not even sh*t about f*cking up why me please y'all get sued hey dude y'all not gonna help me out but you should have why y'all didn't have a body cameras on why y'all didn't have body cameras on then y'all gonna suffocate me in the car you wanna go to the station go to the station I'll go with you 1 0 5 3 7 2 this way yes I will grab this stuff because you're under arrest you're under arrest the responding officers receive an a minus the constitutional analysis is straightforward under United States versus Watson a warrantless arrest in a place accessible to officers supported by probable cause and authorized by the possessor satisfies the Fourth Amendment probable cause here was over determined on use of force Graham versus Conner 1989 governs The Supreme Court prescribes objective reasonableness weighing severity of offense immediate threat and active resistance the officers deployed only verbal commands and guided escort the lowest rungs of the force continuum no weapon was drawn no strike was delivered the tactical decision to deplane uninvolved passengers before initiating physical control reflects sound confined space doctrine the grade is withheld from a full a only because a stray background remark fell beneath the verbal professionalism expected the subject receives an F the recurring assertion of entitlement based on ticket possession is legally incorrect under section 44,902 her sustained noncompliance converted a civil boarding dispute into multiple criminal offenses alleged threats against crew if credited expose her to federal prosecution independent of any state charge accusations of excessive force voiced on camera are directly refuted by the same camera Spirit Airlines personnel receive a B+ the refusal of boarding was lawful the escalation to law enforcement rather than self help was procedurally correct the grade is held below an a because the initial jet bridge breach reflects a procedural gap in gate security not individual fault the woman was arrested and faced a slew of charges including disorderly conduct and destruction of aircraft she was eventually sentenced to probation she stated to the judge that she was wrong but that the employees should have been nicer to her additionally she had been arrested two years prior for something very similar where she assaulted an employee at a fast food restaurant this wasn't improvised let's examine what the law authorizes and what it doesn't three lessons emerge from this record first for travelers a ticket is a contract not a right of entry once refused compliance and later remedy through the carrier's complaint process or civil court is the only lawful path second for law enforcement patience is not weakness clearing a cabin before initiating physical control costs minutes and saves liability third for carriers the front line of aviation security begins at the gate not at the aircraft door procedural gaps at boarding invite precisely the incidents federal law was designed to prevent let us know if there is an interaction or legal topic that you would like us to discuss in the comments below thank you for watching and don't forget to subscribe to our channel for more content on police court interactions