hey guys have a seat we are good bro I'm having a whole a whole bad a bad a bad day no that's my girlfriend we are OK bro young man yes talk to me we just having a bad disagree yeah y'all have been having a bad a bad day and you almost didn't even make it out of here he got a text message from somebody that said I was doing something and he wanted to believe it and hit me in the freaking mouth with his phone stop unless you wanna go to jail and that's a bomb alright so there's a lady that came up to me and said that somebody over by American was assaulting a woman I told her to come get you guys I don't know what she wants American where she didn't tell me that's what I'm saying I told her to come get you American woman she just said over there somewhere but I was like okay say do me a favor there's a police officer I'll walk to Diana Diana and we're good no problem 10 4 10 4 s 0 3 hey guys have a seat we are good bro I'm having a whole a whole bad a bad a bad day no that's my girlfriend we are OK bro young man yes talk to me we just having a bad disagree yeah y'all have been having a bad a bad day and you almost didn't even make it out of here so what's the problem I'm trying to make it out of here right now I'm good you can ask her if she's okay and everything come on lady let's go take a walk 31 31 just make sure you're recording at Echo 2 not Echo 3 I'm at Echo 3 apparently you're not you're not you're not good morning ask her ask her I'm at Echo 2 talk to her ma'am are you here with them or do you are you here with them I literally I just said out pick another seat yeah yeah I appreciate you right I'm sorry I'm trying to sit here on my gate and go I know I know you OK babe you alright everything's alright babe you gonna stop crying or talk to me what's going on man bro like this shit we just having a bad shit bro that shit we get on the flight go home and go our way bro that's how whatever it is it's verbal so you can still talk to me cause no one saw anyone hurt anyone right what's her name her name is Gia she's good you don't need to stop talking we're about to argue man hey do me a favor listen to me hey we're about to argue so stop hey do me a favor stand over there with him okay you can leave it right there man put in your pocket I'm about to I'm about to hello ma'am do you need police assistance do you need police assistance ma'am listen stop crying and just tell me what's up real quick okay I'll help you out if I can I'm not gonna be mean to you I'm not gonna be a jerk but you gotta tell me what's up wait honey I can't I can't I can't understand you if you're crying so chill for a minute and then kind of give me an idea where are you guys going you traveling together I'm going to Buffalo are you guys married no just boyfriend and girlfriend why are we here again now no we just heard so I'm touching you we're here because we have to stay on that side please can you come up to me we're here because we had a disagreement that's it feel me then we was talking we just keep having an argument back and forth is this an ongoing argument that y'all know we we done with the argument it's over we was sitting there chilling talking you feel me but it's people keep calling us telling that my girlfriend is cheating on me you know what I'm saying and she told me that she not whatever and I'm believing I just wanna get home I just wanna get home that's it were you fighting before you came to the airport or it started here it started here why first off we got kicked off the first plane why and then because of an altercation the girl thought she heard him say something and then that altercation happened a girl like the employee yeah the employee okay so then she he got us kicked off the plane okay and then so I went with him cause obviously he bought my sister whatever right and then um he came back yeah then he started screaming that we came here he got a text message from somebody that said I was doing something and he wanted to believe it and hit me in the freaking mouth with his phone so he wanted to believe some stupid shit on the phone something on his phone okay that you were doing something wrong but you weren't I'm so sorry I'm the manager can I see your boarding pass for a second he has he has everything okay so so then he started accuse you of whatever nonsense and it wasn't true yeah okay and then what and he was on my face okay and then you were arguing back and forth after that no that's what I screamed when I got oh you were screaming because he was up in your face no cause he hit me in the face with the phone with the phone okay I don't care alright hold on babe don't yell because here's the thing when you guys were going there to Buffalo you gonna see your people or his people we live together in the apartment we do we live up there or down here in Buffalo you and him live together in Buffalo coming from so you're going home you're not gonna see somebody okay here's the thing if you guys if forget what he's doing right now you have to remain calm and be chill or they're not gonna let you fly so like don't yell over there don't like get like with it like him right just listen to him real quick listen to him so this is where we're at you and him have a ticket to leave right Jesus 30 go ahead 30 go ahead this is your passport correct yes we are thank you yes we are thank you been trying to get out of here all day right anymore interaction with us they're gonna cancel all of your tickets and then you're gonna have to go to Miami that's what she's telling her this is the last place you can actually fly out of at this time you understand what I'm saying what I'm saying is we're gonna give you a chance to get on your plane and leave but no more dramatics no more dramatics nobody was hitting dramatic ma'am I'm not accusing you're not acting dramatic I'm tired of letting this little why embarrassing us throughout the whole airport here's the thing man I don't care you were talking to me a second ago that's not the way you were talking to me yeah because he came in here i'mma walk away I'm gonna walk away alright so so let me ask a question cause I'm about to deny her boarding but what about that gentleman is he one of them gotta get out they've been going from gate to gate to gate and probably airport to airport whatever they had issue wherever they were at but they're still together so we need to separate them they had an issue somewhere else here she don't want to talk to me but she's making accusations now about something that happened somewhere else and I don't have time for that we don't need any drama here alright so you can't cancel them we can rebook them at separate but we want them out so he can go first and then she can go on the next flight OK can you do that yeah we can do you need the passport I have to go to work I can't OK OK what's your final destination both of us alright leave her alone he can go next so no nope I'm making that decision right now you're not leaving with me whatever happened whatever happened yes it's still here OK cause y'all bought it here right alright so right now you're gonna walk out with this gentleman we're gonna rebook you there's no more question there's no more that's there's no more no let's go can I get on this plane no she get on the next one no I will pay for her to get on the next one I already told you no move I'm a I'm a patient stop talking to her man just walk stop unless you wanna go to jail and that's a bomb alright keep walking guys sorry OK put your hands on your back I'm not even doing that hey hey hey hey relax I need to relax bro I just relax bro I'm pissed off bro please y'all please y'all can you take me to my gate man you're under arrest please can you take me to my gate bro please all I did was fall bro I'm pissed off bro I'm mad I'm not acting stupid bro I'm really just mad as hell y'all don't understand what I went through today I got a whole funeral to go to at 5:00 and y'all not understanding this ma'am stay here can I get the the money at least or the or my charger he's not gonna give it up and I can't take it from him oh the charger in the in his pocket my phone's gonna die I know but I have a stop somewhere though sir my my phone's gonna die I will see if I can get it please come back and sit down I missed the funeral already my great grandmother what the hey you really gonna let these people do this to me in the airport doing it to yourself you love me like that's crazy bro that is crazy my love that's crazy lift me up guys please can y'all lift me up I'm not doing nothing I'm contained bro like that I'm contained bro there's only money in my my stuff hey he's got a bunch of money can someone grab this can you please not arrest me can I go to the one bring your knees up to your chest 2 3 bro can you walk me to the gate bro that's crazy yeah that's crazy that's crazy i'mma calm down Mister Harris please just take me to my gate please guys I don't even please I don't even know the laws out here bro I don't know that he's saying that I have to fight by myself ma'am ma'am he needs your boarding pass again he's right in front of my face I hope they don't kick me off the flight either because I have no money no car no ma'am I'm gonna give you a refund okay so you're gonna have to book a no sir I I sir I don't have no I sir I really don't he really got me here to pay for my whole dress I can't I really can't sir can you talk to him about my ring I can try but I really can't OK calm down calm down again please calm down I do everything for that girl everything she didn't put you in jail buddy everything you know I just wanna go home I live all the way in Buffalo New York I got a whole flight five of a of a funeral at 5:00 o'clock what time is it you get what I'm saying I wasn't gonna make it home to eight I already missed my great grandmother passing away like that's crazy wow what can you do with the rest of my belongings buddy can you talk to me I'm not everything you were carrying on here we got okay guys can anybody talk to me though cause this is like really like a lot you feel me like I ain't never been to jail here I have no family here nothing it's only me I hear you please don't this one this one please face the corner damn why you doing that I'm I'm what the hell guys you do this all to yourself huh you did this all to yourself no many times listen to me listen to me I'm done listening to you why are you on that cause I'm done you don't know how I feel you don't know how I feel bro you don't know how I feel you said enough huh you said enough how you feel we know we know your feelings we're going to tell I understand that but you're not saying I did stop I did stop you're not understanding what happened I did stop we were just having a talk we were talking to each other right then and there there's 100% no way to get her out of here probably what if she has a meltdown well I think the the whole thing just had to do with him now that he's gone she's probably fine now that they're separated and that this is done and over with he's he's leaving he's going to jail so she's by herself now I don't think there's anything to worry about with her at this point she's by herself but come talk to her we'll do it you know together and make sure listen listen listen I'm gonna talk hear me out for a second I I get it shh shh hear me out shh last thing I wanna have is a fight at 30,000 feet that's gonna create a lot of problems for 150 70 passengers alright so I'm gonna let you go I'm gonna let you go on board I'm gonna let you fly please just keep quiet OK this is a passenger right now but I understand there was a situation with that gentleman so at this point you're gonna fight just alright so do not antagonize with staff or with the flight attendants OK you're your problem's not dealt with he's gone you understand what he's saying right like they're gonna let you go but they're trusting the fact that you're gonna behave and and not argue with somebody else later you know if you listen I'm gonna tell you this right now I cannot be any more serious if you guys get up in the air and one of those flight attendants says something and you say something back and it turns into an argument they're gonna land that plane the closest airport to wherever they're at and they're gonna take you to jail but here's what I told him now that dude is gone you're gonna be okay right now that he's gone is that your boyfriend okay listen it might be your boyfriend and whatever happens when you guys get back to Buffalo is up to you but right now you said you have to get to work right okay so you gotta be completely chill get on the plane stay to yourself take a nap do whatever you gotta do get off the plane get your bags over there fucking buffalo and go to work his problem he'll deal with it on his own when he gets there he gets there you know what I'm saying you're gonna board you're gonna board at 1:15 the flight's 2:40 you're probably gonna board at 2:00 and you're out of here 45 minutes check out our amazing restaurant you know so to I gave you a charger charge your phone up now you know what I mean that way you got it you're good to go you're gonna have to just chill here can I don't don't touch anything I'm not touching nothing I don't wanna touch anything I just wanna talk so y'all gonna take me to jail yeah hang on can I can I call my mom can I call my mom on my phone please can I call my mom she's all the way in New York this analysis isolates three legal questions from the airport encounter first did the on camera disclosure of domestic violence trigger mandatory investigative duties second does the disorderly conduct charge survive Florida's narrowed statutory interpretation third third does the trespass arrest rest on lawful authority delegated by a commercial air carrier Florida Statute 7 41.28 defines domestic violence to include battery between persons residing together as if a family third the disclosure of being struck in the mouth with a phone falls squarely within that definition Florida Statute 7 41.29 then imposes an independent duty investigate document and identify the primary aggressor this duty does not depend on the alleged victim's cooperation only on articulable probable cause disorderly conduct under Florida Statute 8 77.03 faces a narrower path state versus Saunders 1976 confined the statute to fighting words or conduct creating an imminent breach of peace LB versus State 1997 reaffirmed that limitation loud profane or emotional speech alone is constitutionally insufficient only a conduct based theory persistent refusal to comply supports this charge on the record shown the trespass charge under Florida Statute 8 10.08 rests on firmer ground under Title 49 United States Code Section 4 4 9 0 2 an air carrier may lawfully refuse transport that refusal terminates the passenger's authorization to remain in the secured boarding area failure to depart after a lawful warning by an authorized representative completes every statutory element this is the charge most likely to withstand pretrial challenge THE CONSTITUTION WAS PRESENT AT THIS SCENE THE QUESTION IS WHO UNDERSTOOD IT grades follow from these findings the responding officer earns a B minus strong verbal de escalation and defensible arrest authority but the domestic violence inquiry was incomplete the male subject earns a d for converting a civil refusal of service into criminal trespass the alleged victim earns a C plus deference for distress credit for the on camera disclosure airline staff earn a B for a measured exercise of their federal refusal authority three practitioner lessons emerge from this record first an on camera disclosure of domestic violence creates an investigative duty that survives independently of any other available charge second a carrier's refusal under Section 4 4 9 0 2 converts continued presence into prosecutable trespass the moment a warning issues third moralizing remarks to restrained subjects are legally harmless but consistently erode public trust when footage becomes public record modern de escalation doctrine counsels officers to avoid commentary that lectures or personalizes let us know if there is an interaction or legal topic that you would like us to discuss in the comments below thank you for watching and don't forget to subscribe to our channel for more content on police court interactions